Mark Naison, Fordham University, "With a Brooklyn Accent" blog:
One of the best pieces of New York social history I have read in a long time. Few people have written with greater insight about how race, religion and nationality shape life in rapidly changing New York City neighborhoods.
Led Black, writer, filmmaker, and editor-in-chief of www.UptownCollective.com:
Far too many people still view Washington Heights through the prism of the recent past. Crime, drugs, and rampant lawlessness—all of which scarred the neighborhood in the late '80s and early '90s—are the first things that come to mind. In fact, Washington Heights has emerged phoenix-like from the ashes of the crack years and is experiencing a renaissance that is reshaping and redefining the community. Crossing Broadway tells the complete and true story of this much-maligned neighborhood with erudition, élan, and the soft touch of personal attachment. Robert W. Snyder's book is a testament to the tenacity, dynamism, and vitality of the people who have made Washington Heights their home. If you want to truly understand Washington Heights, then Crossing Broadway is an absolute must-read.
Ira Katznelson, Ruggles Professor of Political Science and History, Columbia University, and author of the Bancroft Prize-winning book, Fear Itself: The New Deal and the Origins of Our Time:
At once analytical, historical, and personal, in this engaging and richly researched community study Robert W. Snyder uses the vantage offered by New York's Washington Heights to illuminate large puzzles of urban change. Ranging across the domains of crime, education, housing, and citizenship, Crossing Broadway reflectively identifies structures, experiences, and agents that, together, compose a decent city.
E. J. Dionne, Jr., author of Our Divided Political Heart and a syndicated columnist:
Crossing Broadway is a brilliant and beautiful book. It brings to the twenty-first-century reader insights—often reflected in the work of Herbert Gans, David Montgomery, and Herbert Gutman—from a long tradition of engagement with the struggles and triumphs of the working people in our great cities. In showing how the residents of Washington Heights linked a devotion to community with uncommon political energy and shrewdness, Robert W. Snyder offers us hope that our nation may yet find a better and more democratic approach to our public life. Crossing Broadway will inspire all who love our cities, who care about popular rule, and who know that the underdogs can win.
Crossing Broadway is an engaging, compelling, insightful study.... There is a good deal here about pride of place, how people struggle and get along and get by day to day in sometimes adverse circumstances, and about how communities are built, and rebuilt, by determined individuals. The book sets a high standard for sensitivity, depth, and excellence in urban community studies.
Snyder's deftly handled descriptions of upper Manhattan are so richly embroidered, and so well researched, that he circumvents the hazards of a mere parochial accounting of his subject. Clearly, he looks kindly on the tenacity with which residents and others have fought crime, poor schools, gangs, landlord neglect, and myriad other urban travails.
Robert Snyder provides an intimate portrait of the urban experience. And like all urban histories of the twentieth century, we know that this will end in crisis. Yet Washington Heights lets Snyder move block by block as this transformation comes. Perhaps most telling is Snyder's own backstory; Washington Heights was the neighborhood of his parents who, though they left the neighborhood for the suburbs, still spoke highly of the place.
Crossing Broadway is a traditional community study and also a beautiful narrative. It will be of interest not only to professionals who engage with the urban landscape but also to those who work with oral histories on many levels.... At once both comprehensive and compelling, Crossing Broadway gains much of its traction by illuminating the individual ways in which residents developed their devotion to their community, demonstrating successful methods for improving public life. Hearing directly from the immigrants and their children makes them real; it touches our hearts and makes them open, truly a great measure of the success of any book.
Drawing on research studies, oral histories, and contemporaneous reporting, Snyder'swell-paced narrative projects the neighborhood's serial make-overs against the backdrop of Gotham's turn from postwar industrial and corporate colossus to a place where manufacturing jobs, white people, and corporations seemed to depart all at once. Historians of the city will find much to think about in this stylish, well-researched, and balanced popular history.
