A Philosophical Retrospective: Facts, Values, and Jewish Identity

Alan Montefiore

Published by Columbia University Press 2011

A Philosophical Retrospective

Facts, Values, and Jewish Identity

Alan Montefiore

In the series Columbia Themes in Philosophy

https://doi.org/10.7312/mont15300

Overview
Contents

About this book

As a young lecturer in philosophy and the eldest son of a prominent Jewish family, Alan Montefiore faced two very different understandings of his identity: the more traditional view that an identity such as his carried with it, as a matter of given fact, certain duties and obligations, and an opposing view, emphasized by his studies in philosophy, according to which there can be no rationally compelling move from statements of factwhatever the alleged facts may beto "judgments of value." According to this second view, individuals must in the end take responsibility for determining their own values and obligations.

In this book, Montefiore looks back on his attempts to understand the nature of this conflict and the misunderstandings it may engender. In the process, he illustrates through personal experience the practical implications of a characteristically philosophical issue. Montefiore finally settles on the following: while everyone has to accept that facts, including those of their own situation, are whatever they may be, both the "traditional" assumption that individuals must recognize certain values and obligations as rooted in those very facts, and the contrary view that individuals are ultimately responsible for determining their own values, are deeply embedded in differing conceptions of society and its relation to its members.

Montefiore then examines the misunderstandings between those for whom identity constitutes in effect a conceptual bridge connecting the facts of who and what a person may be to the value commitments incumbent upon them, and those for whom the very idea of such a bridge can be nothing but a confusion. Using key examples from the notoriously vexed case of Jewish identity and from his own encounters with its conflicting meanings and implications, Montefiore depicts the practical significance of the differences between these worldviews, particularly for those who hove to negotiate them.

Author / Editor information

Alan Montefiore, formerly a fellow and tutor in philosophy at Balliol College, Oxford, is president of the Forum for European Philosophy at the London School of Economics. He has researched and published on a wide variety of topics, including moral and political philosophy, contemporary French philosophy, philosophy of education, and issues of identity and responsibility. He is the author and editor of a number of books, including Philosophy in France Today, The Political Responsibility of Intellectuals, Modern Introduction to Moral Philosophy, British Analytical Philosophy, and Philosophy and Personal Relations: An Anglo-French Study.

Reviews

Mitchell Silver:
...learned, provocative, and insightful...

offers fresh insight to patient readers seeking to understand their place in the world as individuals and members of multiple communities, as long as they enjoy the journey and do not fret about reaching the destination.

Charles Taylor, author of A Secular Age:
A Philosophical Retrospective offers an illuminating exploration of the complexities and ambiguities of the modern notion of identity, so central to today's politics. Alan Montefiore examines this notion against two radically different backgrounds: the fundamental philosophical issue of the relation to facts and values, and the highly particular features of his own situation as a contemporary Jew. His book demonstrates the depth and resonance that this dual background can give to the discussion. It is exemplary of what philosophy can do (but rarely does): relating the viscerally felt dilemmas of life to the most universal issues of thought.

Michael Rosen, Kennedy School of Government:
Alan Montefiore has been thinking about issues concerning morality and identity for a long time. You could say that academic fashion has now caught up with him. What is more, several of those who have brought these questions to the fore are his long-time friends and conversation partners. I am thinking, in particular, of Bernard Williams, Alasdair MacIntyre, and Charles Taylor, not to mention Jacques Derrida. So what Montefiore says about these thinkers' ideas has the extra interest of emerging from personal engagement. For all of these reasons, this is a welcome book.

Akeel Bilgrami, Columbia University:
Alan Montefiore, who taught and influenced some of the most prominent philosophers writing today, was among the first to have realized that so-called 'analytic' and 'continental' philosophy are merely two dramatically different idioms in which the same issues get discussed, at their best, in depth and with rigor. This book on identity brings to bear his subtle and longstanding philosophical preoccupation with the fact-value distinction on his lifelong individual and intellectual struggle with the question of Jewish identity. Its conclusions will no doubt be considered controversial by some. Yet even those who do will find the form in which they are presented to be an appealing mix of detached analysis and genuine feeling rare in current philosophy.

Topics

Frontmatter Publicly Available Download PDF	i
Contents Publicly Available Download PDF	v
Introduction Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	vii
1. Facts and Values? Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	1
2. Identity, Responsibility, and Belonging Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	8
3. Jewish Identity 1: “choosing our identity”? Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	56
4. Jewish Identity 2: the universal and the particular Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	79
5. Jewish Identity 3: a purely secular version? Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	102
6. An Attempt at Pulling Together Some Threads— and an Inconclusive Conclusion Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	116
7. Some Extended Postscripts Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	143
Notes Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	173
Index Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	189

Language: English
Publisher: Columbia University Press
Audience: Professional and scholarly;
Pages
- Main content: 216

eBook

Published: March 14, 2011
ISBN: 9780231526791