FIRST PRIZE IN THE CATEGORY OF NON-EUROPEAN HISTORY
Awarded for 2009 by H-Soz-und-Kult
"With its depth of theoretical insight and the wealth of empirical material this volume sets new standards for the history of colonialism and genocide"
“…an impressive achievement [to be used) as a core text for graduate and upper-- undergraduate courses in genocide studies…The book deserves to be read straight through; it maintains an admirable consistency of tone, purpose and scholarly quality through more than 450 pages. Specialists in the field will wish to add it to their collections immediately." · European History Quarterly
“…much of the material in this book is thoughtful and thought provoking, particularly for those with academic or political interests in imperialism and colonization…[There are many] thought-provoking considerations that the probing contributions to Moses’ volume on genocide will raise among careful readers.” · H-Net Reviews
“The essays in it establish the historical record of genocide in ways both verifiable and meaningful and thus, in a sense, permit future scholars to advance our ability to explain the ultimate political question of this or any time. This excellent volume certainly deserves the tribute of further scholarly and theoretical effort.” · Holocaust and Genocide Studies
“The theoretical and empirical are linked in this stimulating volume in an exemplary manner.” · Zeitschrift für Genozidforschung
“There is still so much to be understood and interpreted about the intersections of empire, colony and Genocide, and the pieces gathered here by Moses are successfully informative and thought-provoking.” · Journal of Australian Colonial History
“…a fine body of work. The essays cannot examine every example of genocide, but collectively they represent a starting point for students, scholars and general readers. For this reason, I wholeheartedly recommend this book for high school and university courses alike.” · Canadian Journal of History/Annales canadiennes d’histoire
“Moses has gathered an elite cohort of scholars with unrivalled expertise. Still, he makes no claim to comprehensiveness and I must follow his example. It is way beyond any review to do justice to the wealth of research and interpretive insight in all of these contributions. So let me say at the outset: the book is essential reading for anyone grappling with the deep and often intractable issues that confront us as historians of genocide.” · Borderlands e-journal
“The essential problem of the book – its recurrent question as well as its potential pitfall – is the position of the Holocaust in relation to other acts of extermination…This creates a tension throughout the book; it also makes it worth debating and certainly makes it a remarkably useful text to inform further research and for teaching purposes.” · Journal of Global History
“...the volume offers an unusually rich, deeply disturbing material.” · Peripherie
“Empire, Colony, Genocide represents an important contribution to genocide studies. Taken individually or collectively, the contributors should be applauded for some thoughtful, methodologically sophisticated, and intellectually rigorous work ... What this volume provides, therefore, is stimulus to further analyze the social, economic, and cultural threads that fostered this complexity, and rationalized genocidal violence.” · Journal of Genocide Research
"Crossing broad temporal ranges and geographies, the collection represents a significant advance in genocide scholarship in its fusion of ostensibly unconnected episodes of mass violence, mass migrations, and nation building projects. It also represents a critical attempt to revisit the impact of murderous impulses in Western modernity as a structural logic with definable processes and actively pursued outcomes of domination and erasure of the colonised” · Australian Journal of Politics and History
“In summary, this is a book that proposes a daring thesis, namely that genocide since antiquity has its origins in imperialism and colonialism.” · Journal of World History
“The volume is disturbing and provocative reading. It raises fundamental methodological and conceptual notions related to genocide. It thereby positions genocide studies in their own right much independent of the hitherto largely dominant Holocaust studies, and situates the latter in a wider context. It is a context of a modern history of violence, which emerged in its still existing forms hand in hand with the industrial mode of production.” · New Routes, A Journal of Peace Research and Action
"An immensely stimulating volume ... [that] meets the challenge to make this kind of mass violence ... a subject ... of global historical importance. It brings together in an innovative way the ‘crime without name’ as it is sometimes called ... with settler colonialism. This approach thus provides a common framework for fields of research that until then were thought to be disparate. Without relativising the genocide of the European Jews, which was in the minds of Lemkin and the UN Convention, new cross references are nevertheless being trialled." · H-Soz-u-Kult
"This volume offers an important contribution to the discussion on methodological and conceptional foundations of the notion of genocide in that it identifies the latter more precisely and anchors it more firmly in historical epistemology than has been the case up to now in Genocide Studies… Second, this volume reflects new developments in Genocide Studies in its focus on ‘Genocide from Below’… Third, some contributions stand out because of their daring and unconventional approaches [which should be] an encouragement for others to abandon scholarly blinkers." · Sehepunkte
"…a meticulously researched and deftly edited scholarly reference…strongly recommended to community library history collections and any non-specialist general reader with a strong interest in world history." · The Midwest Book Review
